310-657-0123 | Osborne Head & Neck Institute

Linda Ronstadt Unable to sing: Singers and Parkinson’s Disease

About Dr. Reena Gupta

Dr. Reena Gupta is the Director of the Division of Voice and Laryngology at OHNI. Dr. Gupta has devoted her practice to the care of patients with voice problems. She is board certified in otolaryngology and laryngology and fellowship trained in laryngology, specializing in the care of the professional voice.

View All Posts

 

Music icon Linda Ronstadt recently announced that she has been diagnosed with Parkinson ’s disease. Although the diagnosis came as a surprise to her during a recent consultation with a neurologist, she states that multiple warning signs were evident long before.  The most difficult and shocking admission was that the longtime singer declared that she “can’t sing a note.”

“No one can sing with Parkinson’s Disease. No matter how hard you try,” she stated in an interview with the AARP.

We have recently seen other entertainment personalities, such as Michael J. Fox, continue to work despite the diagnosis of Parkinson’s disease.  How is it that an actor may continue acting but that Ronstadt’s singing career is at an end?

What is Parkinson’s disease?

Parkinson’s disease (PD) is a disorder of the nervous system due to low dopamine that results in movement, cognition, and mood symptoms.

Initially the disease presents with movement-related symptoms such as:

  • Tremor
  • Slow movements
  • Difficulty walking and stiffness

There may also be issues with thinking and depression and anxiety are commonly seen in Parkinson’s patients.

How Does Parkinson’s disease affect the voice?

Even simple voice use (speaking) requires the careful coordination of many muscles. Speech is affected in PD patients because:

  • Control of the many small vocal muscles is difficult
  • Voice modulation (changing pitch and tone of voice) is affected
  • Depression and anxiety can affect voice quality due to fatigue, apathy/indifference
  • Vocal cords can thin (atrophy) with age. Since PD is more common in older patients, vocal cord atrophy makes voice use even more difficult.

How does Parkinson’s disease affect the singing voice?

Singing places a much higher demand on the larynx than speaking. It is the most complex and intense use of the larynx.  Singing requires exquisite breath control, careful control of vocal cord closure, and manipulation of many small muscles for pitch elevation.  Tone is developed by controlling the muscles of the palate, throat, and tongue, and other muscles.

Because PD affects all of these muscles, these tasks become extremely difficult.

Singing with PD requires significant dedication and practice and usually a singer with PD is not able to be as highly functional as they’d like, as in Linda Ronstadt’s case.

What are the treatments for voice problems in Parkinson’s disease?

Treatments directed at decreasing symptoms include:

  • Voice treatment can assist patients with improving the vocal symptoms of PD. The Lee Silverman Voice Treatment (LSVT) emphasizes the treatment of speech disorders associated with PD. Specifically LSVT BIG, a variation of the therapy, has been found to show improvements in voice strength.
  • Vocal injections can be used to further strengthen vocal cords which normally undergo thinning (atrophy) with aging. A laryngologist may be able to decrease symptoms of improper vocal cord closing, as seen in PD, with this simple procedure.

If I have Parkinson’s disease, will I be able to sing?

Being diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease does not mean that you will be unable to sing. There are currently a number of people with PD who continue to sing.  Like most other tasks, singing is improved most commonly with early treatment and careful evaluation of treatment options between you and your laryngologist. The most critical step in determining if you will be able to sing is having a thorough laryngeal evaluation with vocal motion testing. This will enable your laryngologist to determine the cause of your voice symptoms.

Parkinson’s patients may have other voice disorders that are treatable.  It is important to evaluate for these problems before assuming voice problems are due to Parkinson’s.  Videostroboscopy is critical to determine the cause of voice symptoms.

For more information about treatment and evaluation of voice issues seen in Parkinson’s disease, please contact Dr. Reena Gupta M.D., director of the Voice and Swallowing Center at the Osborne Head and Neck Institute.

Read patient stories about Dr. Reena Gupta from The Division of Voice at the Osborne Head and Neck Institute.

To learn more about the voice, click here.

Close Menu